| Date of PNE Debut | Forenames | Surname | Total PNE Goals |
| 19/02/1985 | ROBERT GARY (BOB) | ATKINS | 9 |
| 15/10/1994 | GRAEME | ATKINSON | 9 |
| 01/09/1894 | Robert (Bob) | Barr | 9 |
| 03/04/1971 | JOHN CHARLES | BIRD | 9 |
| 25/08/1973 | FRANCIS | BURNS | 9 |
| 21/12/1912 | Alfred (Alf) | Common | 9 |
| 09/09/1893 | John | Cunningham | 9 |
| 15/12/1934 | John | Frier | 9 |
| 18/12/1965 | BRIAN ARTHUR | GREENALGH | 9 |
| 25/08/2001 | CHRISTOPHER JAMES (CHRIS) | LUCKETTI | 9 |
| 01/04/1904 | William John (Billy) | Lyon | 9 |
| 12/03/1921 | Frederick (Fred) | Marquis | 9 |
| 10/09/1898 | Patrick (Paddy) | Murray | 9 |
| 14/10/1978 | DONALD JOSEPH (DON) | O'RIORDAN | 9 |
| 07/11/1901 | Ernest (Dick) | Pegg | 9 |
| 30/04/1904 | Thomas (Tommy) | Rodway | 9 |
| 06/051922 | George Douglas | Sapsford | 9 |
| 01/09/1910 | John William | Thompson | 9 |
| 26/02/2000 | BRETT ASHLEY MARK | ANGELL | 8 |
| 16/03/1907 | George Herberet | Barlow | 8 |
| 01/09/1894 | Robert (Bob) | Blyth | 8 |
| 12/01/2008 | RICHARD DAVID | CHAPLOW | 8 |
| 03/08/2013 | THOMAS | CLARKE | 8 |
| 27/12/1902 | Joseph Edward | Derbyshire | 8 |
| 08/08/2005 | DANIELE SALVATORE ERNEST (DANNY) | DICHIO | 8 |
| 16/09/2008 | STEPHEN WILLIAM | ELLIOTT | 8 |
| 13/12/1989 | MICHAEL ANTHONY (MIKE) | FLYNN | 8 |
| 31/12/1949 | WILLIAM (WILLIE) | FORBES | 8 |
| 02/11/1946 | JAMES RUSSELL | GARTH | 8 |
| 27/10//1900 | Ellis | Green | 8 |
| 31/01/2015 | DANIEL ANTHONY | JOHNSON | 8 |
| 07/08/2004 | YOUL | MAWENE | 8 |
| 09/08/1997 | GARY ANTHONY | PARKINSON | 8 |
| 16/04/1994 | JAMES ALEXANDER (JAMIE) | SQUIRES | 8 |
| 11/10/1913 | Alfred Vickers (Alf) | Toward | 8 |
| 10/08/2010 | BAILEY | WRIGHT | 8 |
| 10/04/1903 | Richard Arthur (Dickie) | Bourne | 7 |
| 01/09/1904 | Arthur F | Brown | 7 |
| 31/10/1953 | LESLIE (LES) | CAMPBELL | 7 |
| 09/12/1967 | RAYMOND OGDEN (RAY) | CHARNLEY | 7 |
| 29/01/1972 | DAVID RICHARD (DAVE) | CONNOR | 7 |
| 18/04/1892 | William H | Greer | 7 |
| 02/10/1999 | BJARKE BERGMAN | GUNNLAUGSSON | 7 |
| 30/10/1897 | Laurence | Halsall | 7 |
| 29/08/1998 | JASON ANDRE SEBASTIAN | HARRIS | 7 |
| 04/12/1948 | JOHN (JACKIE) | KNIGHT | 7 |
| 13/08/2012 | SCOTT BENJAMIN | LAIRD | 7 |
| 06/10/1970 | JOHN | McMAHON | 7 |
| 26/12/1925 | David | Morris | 7 |
| 18/01/2003 | BRIAN | O'NEIL | 7 |
| 15/09/1930 | Edward | Owens | 7 |
| 07/09/1908 | Jack | Platt | 7 |
| 27/08/1921 | Albert Edward (Alf) | Quantrill | 7 |
| 16/09/2014 | CALLUM JACK | ROBINSON | 7 |
| 26/11/1994 | ALLAN ANDREW COLIN | SMART | 7 |
| 21/08/2012 | IDORO AKPOEYERE UJOMA (AKPO) | SODJE | 7 |
| 07/09/1901 | George | Spence | 7 |
| 01/10/1983 | GEOFFREY (GEOFF) | TWENTYMAN | 7 |
| 26/08/1939 | John Edwin (Jackie) | Wharton | 7 |
| 22/02/1947 | JOHN G. (IAN) | WILSON | 7 |
| 26/10/2002 | PAWEL TADEUSZ | ABBOTT | 6 |
| 11/08/2007 | DARREN ANTHONY | CARTER | 6 |
| 03/08/2013 | KEVIN CYRIL | DAVIES | 6 |
| 26/10/1895 | William | Eccleston | 6 |
| 17/10/1936 | William (Willie) | Fagan | 6 |
| 05/09/1959 | JOHN ROWAN (JONNY) | FULLAM | 6 |
| 15/12/1984 | SIMON JOHN | GIBSON | 6 |
| 13/08/2012 | LEE DANIEL | HOLMES | 6 |
| 17/08/1996 | MICHAEL ANDREW | HOLT | 6 |
| 06/09/1902 | John | Hunter | 6 |
| 05/10/1901 | Robert (Bob) | Jack | 6 |
| 29/03/1969 | NORMAN WILLIAM MCLEAN (NORRIE) | LLOYD | 6 |
| 18/03/1967 | JAMES (JIMMY) | McNAB | 6 |
| 13/08/2012 | JEFFREY | MONAKANA | 6 |
| 09/08/1997 | COLIN JAMES | MURDOCK | 6 |
| 21/01/1928 | Gavin | Nisbet | 6 |
| 08/08/2009 | PAUL IAN | PARRY | 6 |
| 11/02/1989 | ANTHONY (TONY) | PHILLISKIRK | 6 |
| 26/08/1978 | ERIC THOMAS | POTTS | 6 |
| 13/08/1994 | MARK DAVID | SALE | 6 |
| 27/04/1907 | William | Sanderson | 6 |
| 30/08/1980 | PETER ANTHONY | SAYER | 6 |
| 14/12/1968 | ALEXANDER MCALPINE (ALEX) | SPARK | 6 |
| 27/08/1988 | NEIL JOHN FREDERICK | WILLIAMS | 6 |
| 07/09/1908 | Arthur | Winterhalder | 6 |
| 20/09/1947 | HARRY | ANDERS | 5 |
| 26/12/1933 | John G | Bell | 5 |
| 30/03/1996 | GARY MICHAEL | BENNETT | 5 |
| 11/10/1975 | JAMES KEITH (JIM) | BROWN | 5 |
| 08/10/2013 | JOSHUA | BROWNHILL | 5 |
| 08/09/2012 | JOEL ALAN | BYROM | 5 |
| 11/12/1926 | Kenneth (Ken) | Cameron | 5 |
| 07/09/1907 | John | Carlin | 5 |
| 06/02/2010 | PAUL | COUTTS | 5 |
| 14/02/2012 | GRAHAM | CUMMINGS | 5 |
| 01/02/2014 | CRAIG MARTIN | DAVIES | 5 |
| 20/09/1890 | Samuel (Sammy) | Dobson | 5 |
| 11/01/1950 | THOMAS HENDERSON (TOMMY) | DOCHERTY | 5 |
| 07/08/1999 | ROBERT WILLIAM (ROB) | EDWARDS | 5 |
| 08/11/1930 | Vincent | Farrell | 5 |
| 22/09/1981 | MICHAEL (MIKE) | FARRELLY | 5 |
| 04/09/1982 | ALAN EDWIN | GOWLING | 5 |
| 11/08/2007 | KARL LEON | HAWLEY | 5 |
| 23/08/1986 | RONALD (RONNIE) | HILDERSLEY | 5 |
| 21/09/1929 | Alfred (Alf) | Horne | 5 |
| 26/12/1947 | HARRY | JACKSON | 5 |
| 13/10/1984 | DAVID EDWARD | JOHNSON | 5 |
| 25/01/2003 | GEORGE | KOUMANTARAKIS | 5 |
| 02/09/1905 | Arthur H | Lockett | 5 |
| 02/09/1912 | John | Marshall | 5 |
| 03/09/1898 | Peter | McIntyre | 5 |
| 29/08/1932 | John (Jack) | Mustard | 5 |
| 08/08/2005 | LEWIS RYAN | NEAL | 5 |
| 13/10/1894 | William (Willie) | Orr | 5 |
| 05/08/2006 | DANIEL ADAM (DANNY) | PUGH | 5 |
| 29/04/1967 | JOHN | RITCHIE | 5 |
| 08/09/1888 | Alexander S (Sandy) | Robertson | 5 |
| 22/09/1888 | David Kennedy | Russell | 5 |
| 13/09/1890 | William S (Billy) | Stewart | 5 |
| 25/12/1953 | KENNETH (KEN) | WATERHOUSE | 5 |
| 22/08/1987 | JEFFREY GEORGE (JEFF) | WRIGHTSON | 5 |