| Player | PNE Debut | Current Club | Signed |
| Patrick Agyemang | 19/11/2004 | QPR | Jan 08 from PNE |
| Gareth Ainsworth | 11/01/1992 | QPR | June 03 from Cardiff |
| Craig Beattie | 04/03/2008 | Swansea | Aug 09 from Sheff.Utd. |
| Wayne Brown | 28/10/2008 | Leicester | July 09 from Hull |
| Andy Carroll | 14/08/2007 | Newcastle | none |
| Neil Clement | 02/04/1999 | WBA | July 2000 from Chelsea |
| Richard Cresswell | 14/03/2001 | Sheff.Utd. | Sept 09 from Stoke (on loan) |
| Andrew Davies | 14/02/2009 | Sheff.Utd. | Sept 09 from Stoke (on loan) |
| Claude Davis | 25/08/2003 | C.Palace | Sept 09 from Derby |
| Yoann Folly | 02/04/2005 | Plymouth | Jan 08 from Sheff. Wed |
| Andy Gray | 27/02/1999 | Barnsley | Aug 09 from Charlton |
| Robbie Kozluk | 08/01/2005 | Barnsley | July 07 from Sheff Wed |
| Jon Macken | 09/08/2007 | Barnsley | Jan 08 from Derby |
| Jay McEveley | 30/09/2008 | Derby | Jan 07 from Blackburn |
| Paul McKenna | 09/12/1996 | Nottm.Forest | July 09 from PNE |
| Tommy Miller | 28/11/2006 | Sheff.Wed. | May 09 from Ipswich |
| Tamas Priskin | 11/03/2008 | Ipswich | Aug 09 from Watford |
| Sean St Ledger | 05/08/2006 | Middlesbro' | Sept 09 from PNE (on loan) |
| Brian Stock | 14/01/2006 | Doncaster | Sept 06 from PNE |
| Lee Williamson | 04/04/2009 | Sheff.Utd. | June 09 from Watford |
| Kelvin Wilson | 28/03/2006 | Nottm.Forest | July 07 from PNE |